On
the recent October Cairngorms trip I described in my
last post Tony Hobbs did an interview with me about the gear I was using. This
should be on YouTube soon. I’ll post a link when it appears. In the meantime
this is a gear and trip piece about an overnight Cairngorms trip I did last
October. It first appeared in The Great Outdoors magazine. I’ve done some minor
editing and updated prices.
Glen
Feshie in the Cairngorms is special at any time of the year but especially in
the autumn. The colours are spectacular, the air is crisp, the haze of summer
is over, the midges gone.
This
trip I walked down the glen, camped in the mouth of the side valley called the
Slochd Mor, and then climbed 857-metre Carn Dearg Mor, an isolated Corbett.
The
early afternoon rain had stopped and the sun was breaking through the clouds as
I set off along the glen. There was just one more brief shower. which ended
with a rainbow curving over the hills. Birches in their bright yellow autumn
raiment stood out against the dark pines.
Leaving
the main glen I turned into the Slochd Mor and camped out in the open, away
from the forest. The sky was still cloudy but soon cleared as the almost-full
moon rose. Jupiter shone brightly but the moonlight was too bright for many
stars to be visible. I spent several hours outside, relishing the beauty and
peacefulness, and left the tent door open overnight so I could look out to the
sky whenever I woke. The night was quiet, the silence broken just once when a
skein of geese called loudly as they raced overhead.
The
overnight temperature didn’t quite reach freezing. I woke to a tent soaked
inside and out with dew and condensation. The gentle breeze at dawn was
strengthening as I set off and I wasn’t far up the Slochd Mor before I needed
my shell jacket, the now strong wind funnelling down the steep-sided narrow
ravine.
At the
top of the glen I turned towards Carn Dearg Mor. The map showed a path and a
track leading up to the ridge. They barely existed. The hillside here has been
planted with saplings as part of landowner Wildland’s plan to restore the
Caledonian Forest. The traces of overgrown tracks I found suggest these were
fading long before this recent planting.
The walk up the hillside isn’t difficult anyway.
On the ridge I joined a
rough vehicle track that led to the little pile of stones marking the summit of
Carn Mor Dearg, the fierce wind driving me along. The views are extensive from
this isolated hill. To the west clouds shrouded the summits. Across Glen Feshie
the Western Cairngorms were dark and sombre. High above a golden eagle drifted
in the wind.
The
broad ridge descending slowly to Carn Dearg Beag was a delight with easy walking
and splendid views. Surprisingly this top has a trig point unlike the higher Carn Dearg Mor.
I descended from the ridge directly into Glen Feshie,
wanting to walk through the bright autumn colours I could see below. Tussocks
and deep heather made for quite arduous walking here and I stumbled in hidden
holes a few times. The forest was worth the effort though, ablaze with gold and
yellow. Some of the big old birches were breathtakingly magnificent.
PLANNING
& PREPARATION
Glen
Feshie was familiar terrain but I hadn’t been up Carn Dearg Mor for many years
and could remember little about it. The map didn’t suggest any difficulties.
Whilst the forecast wasn’t for wintry weather I took gear I knew would be
adequate if conditions worsened. Longer nights meant more time in camp and
possibly walking in the dark so I took two headlamps (easier to swap them over
than change batteries) and enough clothing to keep me warm if temperatures
dropped below freezing. I swapped the trail shoes I’d be wearing all summer for
boots and added warmer clothing, including thick gloves and hat, to my pack. I
did save a little weight as out, thankfully, went midge repellent, mosquito
coils, and head net. I’ll be happy not to see those again until next summer.
Knowing I might be spending twelve hours or more in the tent if the weather was
stormy I chose a roomy shelter, saving a little more weight by not bothering
with an inner tent, again not needed when there are no midges or likelihood of
snow.
EQUIPMENT
Klättermusen Ymer Pack 2.8kg £509 ****
- Likes comfort, pockets,
recycled fabric
-
Dislikes heavy, expensive
-
-
Capacity 75+15 litres
-
Materials Retina®, Econyl® – 40%
Polyamide, 30% Post-Consumer Recycled Polyamide, 30% Pre-Consumer
Recycled Polyamide, 400D, 251 g/m²
-
Closure detachable lid, L-shaped
front zip, zipped bottom
-
Back System
external aluminium frame, harness adjustable in height and width
-
Hipbelt pivoting, dual-density
foam
-
Pockets external lid, internal
lid, 2 zipped side, mesh side water bottle, 2 hipbelt
-
Features front and top bungee cord,
front and top attachment webbing, side straps,
-
Size adjustable fit, body
back length 42 - 54 cm.
-
https://www.klattermusen.com/
External
frame packs just about disappeared over thirty years ago so I was surprised
when I was offered one to test earlier this year. The last time that happened
was in 1987! The Klättermusen
Ymer is a huge pack designed “for longer treks and hikes with a heavier load”
and as well as the external frame has a thickly padded hipbelt, lumbar pad, and
back pad. I first tried it in the winter with a very heavy and unwieldy load
including snowshoes and an Icebox igloo-building tool and found it as good as
could be expected floundering through boggy tussocks and patches of soft snow
before I could use my winter tools. I didn’t think that was really a fair trial
though and wanted to use it on a normal backpacking trip before reviewing it.
This first autumn trip required enough gear to justify using it, though it
wasn’t full. Comfort was good as was stability on the rougher terrain. There
are plenty of pockets and I liked having zipped side ones rather than
open-topped mesh. For big heavy loads and long trips this is a good pack. It’s
made from recycled fabric too. It is heavy and expensive but it should last
well.
Bach
Wickiup 3 tent 1300 grams (with
groundsheet) £720 ****
Recommended
- Likes roomy,
stable, light (without inner)
-
Dislikes expensive,
not available without full-size inner
The Wickiup 3 pyramid tent has been a favourite since I first used it seven
years ago. Back then it was branded Nigor. That company has since been taken
over by Bach Equipment. The Wickiup 3 hasn’t changed however. I especially like
this tent when the nights are long as it’s very roomy.
The Wickiup 3 comes with a full-size inner, which pushes the weight up to
1920 grams, and is designed to sleep 3.
There is a 550-gram half-size inner tent for solo use available as an
extra. I use this in midge season. Otherwise I just take a silnylon
groundsheet, which keeps the weight down to a reasonable 1300 grams for solo
use. The groundsheet can be moved around according to the weather too – at the
back of the tent away from the door if it’s stormy, angled into the door if
it’s calm. I did the latter on this trip, enjoying the views.
Stability is excellent – it has stood up to some big storms over the
years – and it sheds snow easily. I didn’t need it for either of those this
time but the space was welcome.
The cost is high but it should last well and it is versatile.
Sierra Designs Cloud 20 sleeping
bag 875g £300
***** Best Buy
- Likes lightweight,
comforter design, foot vent
-
Dislikes expensive
-
-
Fill 800fp DriDown
-
Shell 15D nylon ripstop
-
Construction box wall
-
Zip no
-
Length regular 198cm, long
213cm
-
Rating comfort -3C, comfort
limit -10C
-
https://sierradesigns.cm
This sleeping bag has
become my favourite in recent years because of the comfort and versatility.
There’s no zip but the bag
still opens wide at the top as there’s a wrap-around comforter than runs over
the top half of your body. You can easily wrap this round you for warmth or
open it up to cool down. It combines the protection of a sleeping bag with the
freedom of a quilt better than anything else I’ve used. I just love being able
to fling the comforter aside and sit up and not have to fumble for a zip or a
drawcord toggle. On the bottom there’s a large uninsulated sleeve designed for
a sleeping mat. I don’t use this as it restricts movement. I find the bag roomy
enough that I can move inside, and it stays under me. On this trip the
temperature fell to 2° and I didn’t need to close the hood to stay warm. In
previous reviews I’ve said the Cloud is one of the most comfortable bags I’ve
ever used. It’s not. It’s the most comfortable bag I’ve ever used.
Optimus
Vega stove 180g £105 *****
Best Buy
- Likes lightweight,
pre-heat tube, inverted canister support
- Dislikes nothing
-
Fuels butane/propane
-
Burner diameter
4.5cms
-
Pot supports width 14.5cms
-
Power output 3700 watts/12,624 BTU
-
https://www.katadyngroup.com
This stove has been a favourite for cold weather
use for many years. It can be used with an inverted canister, which works
better in the cold as liquid fuel is fed to the burner where it is turned to
gas via a preheat tube that runs through the flame. The Vega has flip-out legs
to hold the inverted canister in place. I wasn’t expecting very cold
temperatures but I did have a partially used canister of Primus Summer Gas to
use up. This is designed for 15 to 40°C and it certainly wasn’t going to be
anywhere near that warm. As it was the stove was sluggish until I inverted the
canister so it was a good choice.
The low-profile makes the Vega very stable. It’s
compact when packed as the combined pot supports and legs curve in round the
burner. There’s no built-in windshield but it comes with a separate foil
windscreen. The weight is low for this type of stove.
BOOTS
Keen
Circadia Mid WP 1.28kg (9) ***1/2 £115
- Likes fit, grip, breathability, cost
-
Dislikes forefoot cushioning doesn’t
protect against stones
-
-
Uppers leather/fabric
-
Midsole air-injected high-density foam
-
Outsole Keen.Fusion rubber
-
Sizes 6.5-14
-
https://www.keenfootwear.com
Keen says the Circadia Mid is a simplified version
of the well-proven Targhee boots designed for “beginner outdoor adventurists”.
In use I couldn’t tell the difference between the two boots except in the case
of the midsole. With the Cascadia I could feel stones through this. I can’t
with the Targhees. On this walk I wasn’t on stony ground much so it wasn’t a
big issue and otherwise the boots were fine.
The fit is typical Keen with a wide toebox and a
narrow heel, which just happens to be right for my feet. The uppers are leather
with fabric inserts. Inside there’s a waterproof membrane. In the mostly cool
conditions of this trip breathability was good. The terrain varied from forest
tracks to steep boggy moorland and wet grass. The grip was fine throughout. The
toe bumper is big and hard, which was useful on the descent when I kicked a few
rocks hidden in the heather. Overall the comfort was excellent.
These are good boots at a good price. I prefer the
Targhees though, simply for the underfoot cushioning.
CLOTHING
Keela
Talus synthetic insulated jacket
570g (L) £145
***1/2
- Likes
hood, cost
-
Dislikes
weight, bulk, fleece side panels
-
-
Shell
ripstop nylon
-
Insulation
60gsm Primaloft Gold, stretch-fleece side panels
-
Hood
adjustable, wired peak
-
Pockets
2 handwarmer, 1 chest, 1 inner
-
Cuffs
elasticated
-
Sizes
men XS – 3XL, women 8-20
-
https://keelaoutdoors.com
Expecting
a chilly night and hoping to spend some time outside if the sky was clear I
wanted an insulated jacket that would keep me warm standing round star
watching. The Talus was a test jacket I hadn’t worn before but I was pretty
sure it would be warm enough due to the Primaloft fill. It was too, keeping me comfortable
over a thin fleece and base layer. I don’t think it’s one for temperatures well
below freezing but in the ones just above zero on this trip it was fine.
The
design is fairly standard for an insulated jacket. The best feature is the
hood, which is adjustable and has a wired peak, far better than the simple
hoods found on many similar jackets. The handwarmer pockets are cosy but cut
off by a pack hipbelt which wasn’t a problem as I didn’t wear the jacket while
walking. The chest pocket is smartphone rather than map size, again not an
issue on this occasion. Also not an issue but it could be on other trips are
the fleece panels on each side as these aren’t windproof. They are thick, warm,
and very breathable but I’d rather have a jacket that was completely windproof.
The
Talus kept me warm and I liked the hood. The price is low too. It’s quite heavy
for the warmth provided and bulky when packed though.
Berghaus
Paclite Dynak Jacket 355g (L) £180
**** Recommended
- Likes lightweight, hood,
cost
-
Dislikes no chest pockets
-
-
Materials 2 layer polyester/Gore-Tex
Paclite
-
Hood adjustable/stiffened
peak
-
Front Closure
water-resistant zip with inner flap
-
Pockets 2 handwarmer
-
Hem drawcord
-
Cuffs Velcro
-
Sizes men XS-3XL, women
8-18
-
https://www.berghaus.com
The
Dynak is a lightweight waterproof jacket at a good price. The design is basic
but functional. It’s not a full winter
jacket but it is more substantial and a little stiffer than many other
lightweight jackets. I thought it would be ideal for this autumn walk when I
wasn’t expecting wintry weather but rain and wind were likely. In fact there
was only the occasional short shower and I didn’t really need a waterproof
jacket for that. However the wind on the second day was cold and strong and the
Dynak did a great job of keeping it out and also proved quite breathable.
The
hood gives better protection than many on lightweight waterproofs and has a
peak stiff enough not to deform in the wind. The pockets are clipped by a
hipbelt but still usable. I would have liked a chest pocket but that’s a minor
complaint. There are no underarm zips but the adjustable cuffs are quite wide.
BAM
Newal Bamboo Walking Trousers 575g
(36) £79 ***1/2
- Likes comfort, pockets,
environmentally friendly
-
Dislikes slow drying, heavy
-
-
Fabric
350gsm 65% organic cotton/33%
Viscose bamboo’2% Elastane
-
Pockets
2 open hand, 2 zipped cargo, 2
open rear
-
Waist
belt loops
-
Sizes
men 30-38
- https://www.bambooclothing.co.uk
I have mixed feelings
about these trousers. They are very comfortable and pleasant to wear. But they
also soak up moisture and are slow to dry, as you’d expect, given they’re made
from cotton and viscose, both very absorbent materials. This was the first overnight
trip with them and the legs did get wet setting up camp as there was plenty of
damp vegetation around the site and I did kneel on the wet ground a few times.
The next day when I put the trousers on the wet areas felt cold though they
soon warmed up and once I was walking eventually dried in the wind. I think
overtrousers would be needed more often than with quick-drying trousers in
showery weather. I wouldn’t wear the Newals again if much rain was likely.
The trousers are also
quite heavy and warm. On hot days I’d quickly overheated in them. On this trip
they were ideal. My legs never got sweaty or cold. The fabric isn’t fully
windproof – I can blow through it with a little effort – but it was adequate
for the cold wind high up.
I like the open hand pockets
– no zips to grate on cold hands – and the cargo pockets are useful. The fabric
has a slight stretch so they move with you. The fit is quite loose anyway.
Photographic note: images taken during the trip with the Sony a6000 camera and Sony 18-135 and 10-18 lenses, and the OPPO Find X5 Pro smartphone